Move over store bought, canned Sloppy Joe Sauce! This homemade Old Fashioned Sloppy Joes Recipe is easy, delicious and full of simple, hearty ingredients you probably already have in your kitchen! Ready and minutes and sure to a favorite family dinner any night of the week! A mixture of sweet, savory, tangy and zesty… all between two buns!
Why You Will Love This Old Fashioned Sloppy Joe Recipe
- QUICK AND EASY – If you are busy parents like we are, you are probably looking for easy, no frill family dinners. With just a handful of common pantry staples for ingredients and a couple minutes of prep, dinner is on the table any busy weeknight!
- WHOLESOME – It’s great to know exactly what you are feeding your family. This is why it’s great to make homemade versions of these recipes. Just simple, real authentic ingredients.
- NOSTALGIC – We love making homemade versions of classic meals we ate during our childhood. From Tuna Noodle Casserole and Shake n’ Bake Pork Chops to Homemade Beefaroni, we’ve had a lot of fun going down memory lane with our bellies full!
What Is The Difference Between a Sloppy Joe and a Manwich?
And, while we’re at it? How did the Sloppy Joe even get its name? One version of the story originates in Cuba, where a restaurant served a sandwich based on a ropa vieja. The restaurant also sold iced seafood, and the ice would often melt on the floor. This led to the place eventually being called “Sloppy Joes”.
Another version of the story comes from Sioux City, Iowa. A cook named Joe invented a loose meat sandwich with a tomato sauce. The name Sloppy Joe eventually came around and stuck. Who knows which one is true? Or if even either of them are? If you have another theory, we’d love to hear it in the comments.
So, what about a Manwich? Manwich is simple a canned sauce used to make a quick and easy Sloppy Joe. Yes, it’s probably a little quicker to use the premade, store bought sauce. But not much. And this homemade Sloppy Joe Recipe is so much better. And now you know exactly what you are feeding to your family!
How To Make Old Fashioned Sloppy Joes?
So simple. So easy. For the full, step-by-step instructions, check out the printable recipe card below. But, basically, you’ll just need to brown the ground beef and stir with the onion and the peppers. Drain the grease and add all the other ingredients. Here is what you’ll need to get started, along with some suggestions for substitutions if wanted or needed:’
- BEEF – 1 lb of ground beef. We used 80% lean ground beef. If you want to make it leaner, you can substitute ground turkey or ground chicken to make this a little lighter.
- BELL PEPPER – We used chopped green bell peppers. If you want to use red bell pepper or any other color, go for it!
- WHITE ONION – Again, chopped and sauteed with the pepper and the ground beef. Use yellow onion if you’d like. Or omit the onion altogether if it’s not your thing.
- GARLIC – Minced garlic.
- KETCHUP – Use organic or sugar free ketchup if needed. Or substitute for BBQ sauce for a little more bold and zesty flavor!
- BROWN SUGAR – We used two tablespoons of brown sugar. If you are concerned about it being too sweet, you back off this. Or omit it altogether.
- WORCESTERSHIRE SAUCE – Adds more depth to the flavor of the Sloppy Joe.
- DIJON MUSTARD – I think this is our secret ingredient! Gives this sauce just the kick in the pants that it needs!
- SALT AND PEPPER – To taste.
- CAYENNE – Just a pinch. Totally optional.
- HAMBURGER BUNS – Any of your favorite sandwich bread will do. Pretzel buns would be fun! Or Brioche buns. Anything!
What Can You Do With Sloppy Joe Meat?
Obviously, most of us put it between two slices of our favorite bread and made it a sandwich! But there are some other fun things that you can do with Sloppy Joe Meat. Some ideas are:
- ULTIMATE BAKED POTATOES – Load it on a baked potato with cheese, bacon, chives, sour cream and any other fixings!
- LOADED FRENCH FRIES – Same idea as the potato. Load it up! You’ll probably need a fork for this one!
- MAC AND CHEESE – Lots of people love to add BBQ Pork to their Macaroni and Cheese. Why not add Sloppy Joes too?
- GRILLED CHEESE – Add it to a grilled cheese? Yes, “PLEESE”!
- BURGER TOPPING – Need a massive case of Meat Overload? Add this as a topping to a hamburger.
- QUESADILLA – Put it between two flour tortillas and grill them like you would a Quesadilla. Then, thank me later.
- STUFFED PEPPERS – Great as an appetizer or a meal. Stuff Bell Peppers with Sloppy Joe Meat, top with cheese and bake in the oven to bubbly and melted.
- SLOPPY JOE NACHOS – Do I even need to describe this to you? Load it up!
Storage and Freezing
Store leftovers in an Airtight Container in your fridge. It reheats perfectly fine in the microwave. It should be good in your refrigerator for about 5 days.
Can you freeze Sloppy Joe meat? Yep! Just let it fully cool down and put it in a freezer safe container or a freezer bag. It will be good in your freezer for up to 4 months. Thaw in the fridge overnight. Again, reheating in the microwave is fine.
Can You Make Sloppy Joes In A Crockpot?
Absolutely! So easy to make this in a Crock Pot! Just brown the beef and saute the onion and peppers. Then put all the ingredients into your Slow Cooker. Cook on low for 4-6 hours and high for 2-3 hours.
Notes, Tips and Suggestions
A couple other things to consider.
- TOAST YOUR BUNS – With a name like “Sloppy Joe” we are pretty ok with this being a little sloppy to eat. But your buns CAN get pretty soggy. One way to fight this is to toast them before loading them with the meat.
- ADD SOME HEAT? – Want to make this a little spicier? Add some diced jalapenos while cooking. Or you could add some red pepper flakes!
- ADD SOME VEGGIES – This is a great recipe to sneak some vegetables into. Dice up carrots, bell peppers, zucchini or squash. Your kids won’t even know!
We hope you enjoy this Old Fashioned Sloppy Joes recipe. We’d love to hear how you like it in the comments section. And let us know any variations that you like to use in this recipe. It’s fun to play around with! Serve it with a simple side dish like tater tots, french fries, potato chips or some steamed vegetables!
LOOKING FOR MORE EASY FAMILY DINNERS? CHECK OUT:
- BISQUICK CHICKEN FINGERS
- BISQUICK CHICKEN AND DUMPLINGS
- WALKING TACO CASSEROLE
- CROCKPOT RANCH PORK CHOPS
Homemade Sloppy Joes
- 1 lb ground beef
- 1/2 cup chopped bell pepper
- 1/4 cup chopped white onion
- 1 tablespoon minced garlic
- 3/4 cup ketchup
- 2 tablespoons brown sugar
- 1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce
- 1 tablespoon dijon mustard
- 1/2 cup water
- 1-1/2 teaspoons salt
- 1/2 teaspoon ground black pepper
- pinch cayenne optional
- hamburger buns
- Add ground beef to a large skillet and heat over medium high heat, stirring frequently until browned. Drain grease and return meat to pan.
- Add pepper and onion and heat for an additional 5 minutes or until onions are translucent.
- Add garlic, ketchup, brown sugar, Worcestershire, mustard, water, salt and pepper. Mix well.
- Heat over medium heat until bubbly and boiling.
- Reduce heat to low and simmer for 20 minutes, stirring occasionally.